In the dynamic world of marketing, Chief Marketing Officers (CMO) bear the critical responsibility of selecting the right agency partners through the Request for Proposal (RFP) process. Having observed and analyzed hundreds of RFPs over two decades, a common pattern emerges; most RFPs are well-crafted but lack distinctiveness, and often predicated on the assumption that switching agencies is a panacea for achieving superior marketing results. This assumption hinges on the belief that a new agency will inherently bring smarter strategies, more creativity, better efficiency, and access to exclusive knowledge bases or technological platforms. In certain industries, like the Quick Service Restaurant (QSR) sector, where technological advancements play a pivotal role, this perspective might seem justified. However, the most impactful and enduring agency-client relationships are cultivated when both parties commit to evolve together. To elevate your next RFP and foster a more fruitful agency collaboration, consider these detailed strategies:

1. Encourage a Bidirectional Growth Mindset

The most transformative outcomes arise from partnerships where both the client and agency are open to change. Your RFP should not only solicit information on how the agency plans to meet your current needs but also invite suggestions on how your organization can evolve in tandem with their expertise. This dual focus on growth encourages a more holistic approach to solving marketing challenges and leverages the strengths of both parties. For instance, include questions that prompt agencies to propose how they might facilitate organizational change or enhance your team's capabilities, alongside delivering on traditional marketing objectives. This approach underlines the importance of a partnership that's geared towards continuous improvement and innovation.

2. Deep Dive into Technological Capabilities and Innovation

In sectors where technology is a significant differentiator, your RFP should thoroughly evaluate an agency's technological edge and innovative capacity. Beyond listing their tech tools, request detailed case studies or examples demonstrating how the agency has effectively integrated cutting-edge solutions in past projects. Encourage respondents to share a strategic vision for leveraging technology in ways that align with your brand’s specific needs. This could include asking for a step-by-step innovation roadmap that outlines potential technological implementations, anticipated challenges, and strategies for overcoming these obstacles. By prioritizing technological insight and foresight in your RFP, you can gauge an agency's ability to not just keep pace with but also anticipate and capitalize on digital trends.

3. Cultivate a Partnership Built on Openness and Collaboration

Transparency and teamwork should be foundational elements of your agency partnership. Your RFP should explicitly state your expectation for a relationship characterized by open communication and collaborative problem-solving. This can be facilitated by asking agencies to detail their approach to working with clients, managing disagreements, and fostering a creative and productive working environment. Insights into an agency’s communication style and conflict resolution strategies can offer a glimpse into their company culture and how well it aligns with yours. A partnership that values transparency, respects diverse viewpoints, and encourages collective brainstorming is more likely to produce innovative and effective marketing solutions.


While the structure of many RFPs might remain similar, it's the emphasis on mutual evolution, in-depth technological engagement, and a collaborative culture that can truly differentiate your brand and lead to a successful agency partnership. By implementing these detailed strategies in your next RFP, you not only elevate the selection process but also set the stage for a relationship that goes beyond transactional interactions to become a genuine, transformative partnership. This nuanced approach promises not just a change in agency but a leap towards achieving unprecedented marketing success.

Written By

Daniel Brian Cobb


Date Published

May 21, 2024

Share this blog


Do you have a branding, advertising communications or digital marketing need? Please tell us about it, and a consultant will respond within minutes to set up a no-obligation conversation.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.